National Tax Day is approaching! Don't forget to claim a 30% Solar Tax Credit for your solar system. Read about Solar Tax Credit.
Out of all types of renewable energy, geothermal might be the most mysterious. What is it and how does it work? In this article, we'll explore the pros and cons of geothermal energy, compare it with solar panels, and analyze how these renewable source energies stack up against fossil fuels.
Key takeaways
Geothermal energy harnesses heat from beneath the Earth's surface to generate power and provide heating and cooling for buildings. Unlike solar panels that you can see on rooftops, geothermal systems tap into the constant temperature of the ground below the frost line, which stays between 50-60°F (10-16°C) year-round in most of the United States.
Geothermal energy has been used for thousands of years in the form of hot springs
This renewable energy source has been used for thousands of years in the form of hot springs, but modern applications have evolved to include electricity generation through geothermal power plants and highly efficient geothermal heat pump systems for residential and commercial buildings. As a reliable and sustainable energy source, geothermal energy offers a compelling alternative to both fossil fuels and other renewable options like solar and wind power.
Geothermal power plants tap into underground geothermal reservoirs to harness the Earth's heat and convert it to electricity. These plants typically operate in areas with high geothermal activity, such as regions with hot springs, geysers, or volcanic activity. Geothermal plants use three main approaches to generate power:
These geothermal power plants provide continuous baseline power generation regardless of weather conditions or time of day, contrasting with the intermittent nature of solar and wind energy systems.
For residential and commercial applications, there are several types of geothermal heat pump (GHP) systems:
The United States leads the world in geothermal electricity production with approximately 3.7 gigawatts (GW) of installed capacity, enough to power about 2.7 million homes. Key statistics include:
While geothermal electricity production is geographically limited to areas with accessible high heat resources, geothermal heat pump systems for heating and cooling can be installed virtually anywhere, making them accessible to homeowners and businesses throughout the country.
What's good about geothermal energy and why should we use it more? Let's look at the advantages.
Geothermal energy systems deliver impressive efficiency rates, with heat pumps typically providing 400-500% efficiency compared to the 98% of the most efficient traditional gas furnaces. This means for every unit of electricity used to operate the system, 4-5 units of heating or cooling are produced. This efficiency remains consistent regardless of extreme outside temperatures, unlike air-source heat pumps that lose efficiency in very cold weather.
Additionally, geothermal power plants operate at capacity factors above 90%, meaning they produce power at maximum output over 90% of the time. Compare this to solar power's typical 25% capacity factor, and you can see why geothermal provides exceptionally reliable baseload power.
For utility-scale energy production, geothermal has one of the smallest land footprints of any energy source. A geothermal power plant requires approximately 1-8 acres per megawatt versus 5-10 acres per megawatt for solar PV farms. For residential systems, the ground loops can be installed under lawns, driveways, or landscaping with minimal visual impact once installation is complete.
1-8 acres per MW
– average land footprint of geothermal plants
For contractors and property developers, this space efficiency makes geothermal an attractive option for projects where land use optimization is important.
Geothermal systems are built to last. Ground loops typically come with 50-year warranties and can function for 50-100 years with proper installation. The indoor components (heat pumps) last 20-25 years, significantly longer than the 15-year average lifespan of conventional HVAC systems and comparable to the 25-30 year warranty on premium solar panels.
20-25 years
– average lifespan of heat pumps
For homeowners making a long-term investment, this durability translates to exceptional value despite higher upfront costs. For contractors, it means offering clients a system with unparalleled longevity.
Unlike solar power, which varies with weather conditions and daylight hours, geothermal energy provides consistent power 24/7, 365 days a year. This eliminates the need for battery storage systems that solar installations often require for round-the-clock energy access.
For farmers who need reliable power for livestock facilities or food processing, and contractors working with clients who can't risk power interruptions, this consistency is invaluable.
While initial installation costs are higher, geothermal heat pumps can reduce heating and cooling costs by 40-70% compared to conventional systems. For the average American home, this translates to annual savings of $1,500 or more, depending on local energy prices and climate.
For our target audience of middle to high-income homeowners, this long-term savings profile often justifies the initial investment, especially when combined with available tax incentives and rebates.
Geothermal systems produce virtually no direct emissions during operation. Residential geothermal heat pumps can reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 40-70% compared to conventional heating and cooling systems. Even counting indirect emissions from the electricity used to run the pumps, the carbon footprint is substantially lower than fossil fuel alternatives.
For environmentally conscious property owners, geothermal offers one of the cleanest energy solutions available, with less visual impact than roof-mounted solar arrays.
Not everything is great about geothermal energy. Here are the main disadvatages of it
$15,000-$40,000
– average cost of home geothermal heat pump systems
The most significant barrier to geothermal adoption is the substantial upfront investment. Residential geothermal heat pump systems typically cost $15,000-$40,000 depending on home size, site conditions, and system design. These high upfront costs are 2-5 times the cost of conventional HVAC systems and often comparable to or exceeding the cost of a complete solar panel installation.
The drilling or excavation required for ground loops represents about 50-60% of this total cost. Many homeowners find geothermal systems prohibitively expensive despite their excellent long-term value. For contractors, these high upfront costs present a significant sales hurdle even when showcasing the impressive long-term energy savings that geothermal heating and cooling systems provide. Financing options and federal tax incentives have helped make these systems more accessible, but cost remains a primary disadvantage of geothermal energy for residential applications.
While geothermal heat pumps can work anywhere, large-scale geothermal electricity generation is limited to regions with accessible high-temperature geothermal resources, typically in western states. This geographical constraint means many regions simply cannot develop utility-scale geothermal power regardless of interest or investment.
Not every property is suitable for geothermal installation without significant additional costs. Challenging factors include:
For contractors and installers, these variables can make accurate cost estimation difficult without thorough site assessment.
While generally environmentally friendly compared to fossil fuel systems, geothermal energy does have some environmental disadvantages that should be considered:
These environmental disadvantages of geothermal energy are generally small and manageable with proper design and monitoring compared to the environmental impact of fossil fuels. However, they must be considered in system planning. For homeowners concerned about environmental impact, these disadvantages are typically outweighed by the significant reduction in carbon emissions that geothermal heating and cooling systems provide.
Finding qualified geothermal installers with proper experience can be challenging in many regions. The geothermal heat pump industry suffers from a shortage of trained professionals compared to solar panel installers. Proper system sizing and installation are critical for optimal geothermal system performance, and mistakes can be costly to remediate. This shortage of experienced geothermal installers can lead to higher costs and occasionally suboptimal installations.
For homeowners, this means more due diligence when selecting a contractor. For contractors reading this article, this represents both a challenge and an opportunity to develop specialized expertise in an underserved market segment. As more homeowners seek alternatives to fossil fuel heating systems, contractors with geothermal installation skills are positioned to capture this growing market while many competitors focus exclusively on solar energy systems.
Installing a geothermal system involves significant excavation or drilling, which can disrupt landscaping and property access for days or weeks. Horizontal systems require trenches 3-6 feet deep across large areas, while vertical systems need drilling equipment to create multiple boreholes hundreds of feet deep.
For homeowners, this temporary disruption must be weighed against the long-term benefits, and property restoration costs should be included in project budgeting.
How do geothermal and solar energy fare against each other? Let's look at them in comparison.
When comparing geothermal and solar energy production as renewable source energy options, several key factors come into play:
The economic comparison between geothermal and solar energy reveals important differences in investment profile:
Residential geothermal heat pump systems typically cost between $15,000-$40,000 for installation, which translates to approximately $5,000-$10,000 per ton of capacity. Residential solar panel installations generally run $15,000-$25,000 for a typical 6kW system, which breaks down to about $2.50-$5 per watt. This makes the upfront costs of geothermal energy systems generally higher than comparable solar installations for most homes.
Both technologies currently qualify for a 30% federal tax credit through the Inflation Reduction Act, helping offset these significant upfront costs. Additional state and local incentives may further reduce the net investment required.
When it comes to return on investment, geothermal heat pumps typically reach payback in 5-10 years depending on energy prices and climate. Solar PV systems usually reach payback in 7-12 years depending on local electricity rates and available sunlight. The longer lifespan of geothermal ground loops can provide additional decades of energy savings after the initial payback period.
Geothermal heat pump systems require significant land area for installation. Horizontal ground loops need approximately 1,500-3,000 square feet of available land per ton of system capacity, making them more suitable for rural or suburban properties. Vertical loops require much less surface area at only 350-550 square feet but demand specialized drilling equipment and typically cost more to install. The indoor equipment requires approximately the same space as a traditional HVAC system.
Solar energy systems have different space requirements. They typically need approximately 100 square feet of roof or ground space per 1 kilowatt of system capacity. Solar panels require unshaded, properly oriented surface area, ideally south-facing in the northern hemisphere. Some older homes may need structural reinforcement to support the additional weight of rooftop solar installations.
The installation timelines differ significantly as well. Geothermal systems typically take 1-2 weeks for residential installation, including drilling/excavation and system connection. Solar panel installations are much quicker, usually completed in 1-3 days for typical residential systems.
Factoid with lamp: Geothermal systems cause significant land disruption during installation, requiring landscape restoration afterward. Solar installations involve minimal disruption, primarily limited to roof access and electrical work.
Geothermal heat pumps substantially reduce carbon emissions, cutting greenhouse gases by 40-70% compared to conventional HVAC systems. Solar PV systems produce virtually no emissions during operation after installation. Full lifecycle analysis shows both technologies produce under 50g CO2 equivalent per kWh, compared to 1,000g+ for coal and 400-500g for natural gas power plants.
For environmentally conscious property owners, both technologies offer excellent environmental performance, with geothermal providing slightly better lifecycle emissions in most analyses but solar having fewer installation-related impacts.
This comparison highlights the complementary nature of these renewable energy technologies. For many homeowners, a hybrid approach using geothermal for heating and cooling while solar panels offset electricity usage can create an optimal renewable energy solution.
Both geothermal and solar energy offer compelling advantages for American homeowners, contractors, and farmers looking to reduce energy costs and environmental impact. Geothermal excels in efficiency, consistency, and long-term value despite higher upfront costs and installation complexity. Solar offers easier installation, lower initial investment, and excellent scalability, though with less consistent energy production.
As federal tax incentives continue to support both technologies equally, the choice ultimately depends on your specific property characteristics, energy needs, and long-term goals. By understanding the distinct advantages and limitations of each system, you can make an informed decision that delivers decades of reliable, sustainable energy for your home or business.
Find your best solar panels!
Take a look at the brands we have in stock and get a quote for a system from our engineer.
Shop solar panels
Andrei has been a news editor and freelance writer for a number of medias before joining the A1 SolarStore. Climate change and its impact on people's lives have always been among his interests and it partially explains his degree in Philosophy and Ethics.
More articles from this authorStay tuned
Learn about the latest arrivals and discounts first!
Solar panel efficiency: What you need to know
How much do solar panels cost to install? Up to you!
